The 2026 Mock Draft for the Steelers: Exciting Changes Ahead!
It’s amazing how quickly fortunes can shift in the NFL. Just a year ago, two teams that were largely overlooked are now competing in the Super Bowl today. This serves as a powerful reminder of the league's unpredictable nature. A strong draft class and new coaching staff have been instrumental in these transformations, which offers hope to organizations like the Pittsburgh Steelers. As they look forward to the offseason, the Steelers are equipped with an impressive total of 12 draft picks and a fresh coaching team under Mike McCarthy’s leadership.
In fact, it has been since 1992 that the Steelers last made 12 selections in a single draft—a time when the draft consisted of 12 rounds! Even if the Steelers decide to combine some of their picks to move up the board, this presents a unique opportunity to revamp their roster and set the stage for their next championship pursuit.
Given that we’re still early in the drafting process, mock drafts are not so much about making accurate predictions but rather about exploring a range of possibilities. The following mock draft reflects my personal strategy for the Steelers. Although I usually refrain from suggesting trades in these scenarios, the sheer number of picks the Steelers possess makes at least one trade-up seem almost inevitable.
Without further delay, let’s dive into my first version of the 2026 Steelers mock draft.
Round 1 – Trade Up* – Caleb Downs, Safety, Ohio State
Trade: Steelers send their first-round pick along with two third-round picks, while the Dolphins send their first-round pick back.
Caleb Downs is an elite talent, and it’s a rare occasion for the Steelers to have the opportunity to select someone of his caliber. Will he still be available by then? Historical trends suggest he could be. For instance, since 2018, Minkah Fitzpatrick holds the record as the highest-drafted safety, going 11th overall. The safety position remains undervalued across the league. Even if Jalen Ramsey remains with the team, his skills might be better utilized in a slot/safety role closer to the line, especially considering he isn’t a long-term option at age 31. If Downs can elevate the Steelers' defense, then investing in this two-time consensus All-American is undoubtedly justified.
Round 2 – Omar Cooper Jr., Wide Receiver, Indiana
If the Steelers pass on selecting a receiver in Round 1, it’s essential they don’t leave Round 2 without one. Omar Cooper Jr. would be an excellent choice, bringing versatility as a reliable receiver who can create separation, consistently make catches, and generate yards after the catch with his impressive speed.
Round 3 – Ted Hurst, Wide Receiver, Georgia State
Transitioning to Mike McCarthy’s offensive scheme, the Steelers will need additional receiving options. Hurst stands out as an intriguing prospect if available in the third round. He is a productive, larger receiver known for his refined route running and acceleration. During Senior Bowl week, he made headlines with one of the most sensational catches and showcased his ability to outrun defenders to create opportunities for deep passes.
Round 4 – Nick Singleton, Running Back, Penn State
Some team is bound to snag a bargain with Singleton in the third or fourth round due to his recent foot injury sustained during the Senior Bowl. Why not the Steelers? He possesses the explosive potential they’ve been missing and could emerge as a starting running back within a couple of years, especially as Jaylen Warren and others depart from the team. Singleton excels at running, receiving, and breaking off big plays, and during his time in Mobile, he demonstrated improved blocking skills.
Round 4 – Keylan Rutledge, Offensive Guard, Georgia Tech
It might be optimistic to expect Rutledge to still be available here, but guards often tend to fall in the draft for various reasons. Rutledge is an exceptionally aggressive player who could provide a pivotal addition to the Steelers’ young and promising offensive line. Coaches had to advise him to dial back his intensity during Senior Bowl practices because he was dominating opponents too frequently. I’m definitely in favor of adding a player with that kind of tenacity.
Round 5 – Domani Jackson, Cornerback, Alabama
A cornerback with both size and a background in track makes for an enticing developmental pick in the later rounds. While he needs to sharpen his man coverage skills, he showcases aggression and physicality with enough potential to be intriguing for the Steelers.
Round 6 – James Thompson Jr., Defensive Lineman, Illinois
The Steelers are committed to maintaining their 3-4 defensive setup, meaning they must continue acquiring those rare body types capable of playing at defensive end in this alignment. Thompson, standing at 6’6” and weighing 310 pounds, brings a solid background from Wisconsin before transferring to Illinois. The Steelers have a history of favoring Wisconsin products on defense.
Round 6 – Barion Brown, Wide Receiver, LSU
Brown had a standout performance during Senior Bowl week, clocking the fastest top speed among all receivers present. He demonstrated his ability to create separation in routes and make challenging catches even in tight situations. While the Steelers may not require three new receivers, Brown represents excellent value at this point and adds depth as a return specialist, having recorded six kick return touchdowns over four years in college. With practice, he could likely transition into a proficient punt returner as well.
Round 7 – Bryce Boettcher, Linebacker, Oregon
Boettcher was drafted in Major League Baseball but has opted to pursue a football career instead. Based on his performance at the Senior Bowl, it’s clear that football is the right path for him. He displays physicality, athleticism, and strong communication skills, with the added bonus of being proficient in coverage. He could contribute immediately on special teams, with the potential to grow into a more significant role.
Round 7 – Jack Stonehouse, Punter, Syracuse
While I usually wouldn’t endorse selecting a punter in the draft, I’ve grown weary of the inconsistent punting seen in Pittsburgh. Stonehouse appears to be an NFL-level punter, showcasing impressive hangtime and remarkable reliability.
And there you have it! What are your thoughts on these potential picks? Do you agree with this strategy, or do you think the Steelers should take a different approach? Let's discuss!
