Get ready to be moved, because the heartwarming and critically acclaimed musical Come From Away is getting a fresh, innovative twist at the Paper Mill Playhouse—and it’s unlike anything you’ve seen before. But here’s where it gets exciting: this reimagined production isn’t just about the story; it’s about the talent bringing it to life. Jeannette Bayardelle, Andréa Burns, Lisa Howard, and a stellar cast of actor-musicians are set to take the stage, blending their acting chops with live musical performances that promise to elevate the show to new heights. Directed and choreographed by the visionary Richard J. Hinds, this version of Come From Away is poised to captivate audiences all over again.
And this is the part most people miss: the actor-musician concept isn’t just a gimmick—it’s a bold creative choice that deepens the connection between the performers and the story. Each actor will not only embody their character but also contribute to the live music, creating an immersive experience that feels raw, authentic, and deeply personal. It’s a testament to the versatility of this Tony-nominated musical, which first opened on Broadway in 2017 and went on to earn seven Tony nominations, including Best Musical.
For those unfamiliar, Come From Away tells the true story of 7,000 air passengers stranded in Gander, Newfoundland, following the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. It’s a tale of resilience, kindness, and the power of human connection—themes that resonate now more than ever. But what makes this production stand out is its fresh perspective, thanks to Hinds’ direction and a cast that includes Broadway veterans like Bayardelle (Girl from the North Country), Burns (In the Heights), and Howard (It Shoulda Been You), alongside rising stars like John El-Jor and Nick Gaswirth.
Here’s where it gets controversial: while the original Broadway production, directed by Christopher Ashley, is a beloved classic, this reimagined version dares to ask: Can a new interpretation enhance an already powerful story? Or does it risk losing the magic of the original? We’ll let you be the judge. But one thing’s for sure—this production is not afraid to take risks.
The creative team behind the scenes is equally impressive, with music director Sam Groisser, scenic designer Nate Bertone, and lighting designer Paige Seber, among others, bringing their A-game to the table. And let’s not forget the understudies—Molly Coyne, Travis Darghali, Brandi Knox, and Matthew Whennell-Clark—who ensure the show goes on, no matter what.
Mark your calendars: previews begin February 4, with the official opening on February 8 at the Paper Mill Playhouse in New Jersey. If you’re a fan of Come From Away, this is a must-see. And if you’ve never experienced the show before, this reimagined version is the perfect introduction.
But before you go, we have to ask: Do you think the actor-musician concept will enhance the emotional impact of Come From Away, or is it a distraction from the story? Let us know in the comments—we’re eager to hear your thoughts!
In the meantime, if you’re craving more theater magic, Disney’s Frozen is currently playing at the Paper Mill through January 11, 2026. And looking ahead, the 2025-2026 season also includes 1776 and West Side Story. For tickets and more information, visit PaperMill.org. This is one theatrical event you won’t want to miss!
